Usually, yes, with some sequencing. Apply the eye serum first, let it dry, then a small amount of retinol, then moisturizer, and start two or three nights a week. Simpler still: caffeine serum in the morning, retinol at night. If a dermatologist has prescribed a retinoid, ask them how to sequence a cosmetic serum around it.
Key takeaways
- The simplest split: caffeine serum in the morning, retinol at night.
- On the same night: serum, a minute to dry, a small amount of retinol, then moisturizer.
- Start two or three nights a week, and ask the prescriber how to place a serum around a prescribed retinoid.
Why the question matters under the eye
Retinol is a cosmetic form of vitamin A used for the look of fine lines and texture, and it is one of the few over-the-counter ingredients with a real reputation. It is also drying, and the under-eye is the thinnest, most reactive skin on the face. So the worry is fair: will an eye serum plus retinol be too much for the area? A caffeine and exosome serum is gentle, water-based and layers under almost anything, so it is rarely the issue. The thing to manage is the retinol itself, and the serum can make that easier.
The serum behind this answer
EYE Serum
Caffeine and platelet-derived exosomes with a cooling metal tip, for brighter-looking under-eyes.
$138. Free shipping. Refill and save $14.
The simplest split: serum in the morning, retinol at night
If you want zero decisions, put them in different halves of the day. The caffeine in an eye serum does its job on the look of puffiness in the morning, on clean skin, under moisturizer and sunscreen. Retinol belongs at night, because sunlight breaks it down and because the drying it causes is easier to buffer with a moisturizer you sleep in. On this schedule the two never touch, and you still get the serum's slow-acting half if you also apply it at night before the retinol, which is the next option.
Layering them on the same night
- Cleanse gently and pat the under-eye dry.
- Eye serum along the orbital bone, a grain of rice per eye, tapped in. The EYE Serum goes on here.
- Wait a full minute until the serum has dried to an invisible film.
- A very small amount of your retinol product, tapped over the same area and kept well away from the lash line and the lid.
- Moisturizer or eye cream over the top.
The serum goes first because it is thin and needs bare skin. The retinol goes second because it should be applied over a dried layer rather than mixed into a wet one. The moisturizer goes last as the buffer. Some people prefer to apply moisturizer before the retinol as well, which softens it further; that is a reasonable choice for the under-eye and a common piece of general skincare advice for anyone starting out.
Start slower than you think
Two or three nights a week for the first few weeks, then build up if the skin stays comfortable. Use a low concentration. A rice grain is plenty for both eyes. The mistake almost everyone makes with retinol near the eye is doing too much too soon and then blaming the product, or the serum, for the flaking that follows. Given twelve weeks at a slow ramp, retinol is usually a good experience. Ten nights at full strength usually ends in red, peeling skin.
Do
- Apply the serum first and let it dry to a film
- Use a rice grain of retinol for both eyes
- Buffer with moisturizer over the top
- Take sunscreen to the orbital bone every morning
Don't
- Mix retinol into a wet serum layer
- Let retinol reach the lash line or the lid
- Start at full strength every night
- Move or stop a prescribed retinoid to fit a cosmetic serum
Signs you have overdone it
- Tightness or a dry, papery feel under the eye the next morning.
- Fine flaking that concealer catches on.
- Redness that lasts into the day, or stinging when the serum goes on the next morning.
- Flaking or redness on the eyelid itself, which usually means the retinol migrated.
When any of these show up, drop the retinol for a week, keep the serum and moisturizer going, and restart at a lower frequency. If the eyelid is involved, keep the retinol further from the eye when you do. If redness, swelling or a rash persists, stop and see a dermatologist.
Prescription retinoids are a different conversation
Tretinoin, adapalene at prescription strength, tazarotene and similar products are medicines. If a dermatologist has prescribed one for the eye area or the face, the decision about how and when to use it is theirs, and so is the decision about where a cosmetic serum fits around it. Ask them directly: here is the eye serum I use, here is the ingredient list, where should it go? Do not stop or move a prescribed treatment to make room for a cosmetic one, and do not treat an article like this one as advice on a prescription.
Who should hold off on retinol near the eye
If you are pregnant, nursing or trying to conceive, ask your doctor before using any vitamin A product; the eye serum on its own is a separate question for them too. If your under-eye is already irritated, eczema-prone or recovering from a reaction, get the skin comfortable first and add retinol later, if at all. And if you are new to skincare entirely, the American Academy of Dermatology's advice to focus on one concern at a time is worth taking literally: settle the serum and sunscreen habit for a month before adding anything else.
Sunscreen, every morning, without exception
Retinol makes skin more sensitive to sun, and the under-eye is sun-exposed all day. Broad-spectrum sunscreen taken right up to the orbital bone, over the dried morning serum and moisturizer, is part of using retinol. If that step is not going to happen every morning, leave the retinol out and keep the sunscreen.
If your question is about the rest of the face rather than the eye area, read exosome face serum with retinol.
Read next
What retinol, caffeine, exosomes and the other names on an eye serum label are each for is in eye serum ingredients, explained one by one. The night routine with timings, including where retinol sits, is in a morning and night under-eye routine that takes two minutes. For the serum-or-cream question, start with the eye serum guide.
